← All articles

LNC Governance · Member Access · Transparency

LNC Removes Party Members From the Entire LNC Email Address

A gold envelope outside a locked committee-room gate, with a golden liberty torch beyond it, symbolizing restricted member email access to the LNC

Libertarian Party members can no longer email the full Libertarian National Committee with a single address. A motion to restore public access to entire.lnc@lp.org failed 8 to 10 when voting closed on November 3.

The change began with LNC Chair Evan McMahon. On October 26 he told the board that he had asked staff the day before to return the address to internal use. He said the address was meant for people with LP email accounts and should carry business before the committee. He added that members could still use the Contact Us form on the party website. "No one is blocked from sending to the LNC," he wrote.

At-Large Representative Keith Thompson and Vice Chair Amanda Griffiths asked the board to reconsider. Region 1 Alternate Sonja Feintech then moved to restore access "consistent with longstanding custom and practice." The ballot opened October 27 with Feintech, Griffiths, Region 4 Representative Mimi Robson and Region 6 Representative Alfa Shaw as co-sponsors.

Board members disagreed about how long the public had used the address. McMahon described public access as a recent change. Region 9 Representative Alex Flores said outside members could not write to the address directly until very recently, but Thompson said he holds more than 700 emails from non-LP.org senders to the address dating back to January 2025.

The LNC Contact Form Broke

On October 29, Feintech reported that Region 1 members were using the Contact the LNC form and their messages were not reaching the board. Executive Director Steve Dasbach confirmed the problem. He explained that the form had relied on the Entire LNC address internally and stopped working once the address was changed.

Staff repaired the form that evening.

Two members had already voted against the motion to restore it by then. Region 7 Representative Olivia Hayse and At-Large Representative Steven Nekhaila cast their No votes on October 27 and cited the form as the proper alternative. Neither changed their vote after the outage came to light.

The timing falls inside a series of moves that have narrowed Region 1’s access to the board’s email lists. Martin says he was removed from Entire LNC and every other LNC list in early October, and the board voted 12 to 2 to cut his public-list forwarder. On October 23 he sent the officers a records demand on the CRM sale, joined by Directors Alfa Shaw and Sonja Feintech. On October 24, Montana Libertarian Party Chair Melissa Wong, a Region 1 affiliate leader, wrote to Entire LNC asking for the contracts and independent valuations on that same sale. Feintech forwarded her letter to the public list with Wong’s permission. The next day, Chair Evan McMahon asked staff to restrict the address. That same day the Executive Committee voted unanimously to suspend all of Martin’s rights and privileges pending a November 21 trial. On October 29, Feintech called the timing “extremely convenient” for keeping members from writing in during a public relations crisis.

The change also removes a layer of transparency. Entire LNC was the one address that put a member’s message in front of every director at once for all to see. The form that remains stopped delivering to the full board when the address changed. The Chair has also repeatedly told Region 1’s elected representative to stop speaking on official email channels. Vice Chair Amanda Griffiths said added steps mostly stop well-intentioned members, and Shaw said turning members away damages the party’s image as a transparent, bottom-up organization. Members who once wrote to the whole board in one step now face a narrower door.

The Debate Over Member Email Access

Flores argued that the board's inbox should stay focused on party business. "It is a business list, not a public forum or members soapbox," he wrote. He listed other channels members can use, including individual emails, Discord and social media.

Shaw said closing the address "injures our image as a transparent bottom up organization." At-Large Representative Richard Longstreth said the form's email confirmation step helps filter spam. Griffiths argued that extra steps mainly discourage well-meaning members rather than spam. She added that board members can block an abusive sender's email address, but they have no such option for messages that arrive through the form.

Voting Yes were Dustin Coffell, Griffiths, Susan Hogarth, Treasurer Doug Knebel, Sonja Feintech, Mimi Robson, Alfa Shaw and Keith Thompson. Voting No were Tyler Danke, Flores, Joe Hannoush, Hayse, Longstreth, McGee, Nekhaila, Nguyen, Redpath, and McMahon. Redpath first voted Yes on November 2 and changed his vote to No minutes later.

How to Contact the LNC Now

Members still have several ways to reach the board.

Use the website form. The Contact Us page has a form where you can choose "Contact my LNC representative." A second form lets you select the entire LNC. You have to scroll all the way to the bottom of the page to find the form. Once you fill out a form, you will receive an email with a confirmation link through Zoho, and the message is not sent until you click it. Pressing Submit on the first screen ends the process without sending a message.

Representatives' addresses are also listed on the party's LNC page and usually follow the firstname.lastname@lp.org format. Ask your representative to forward it. Your regional representative or alternate can send your message to the full board.

Members can also follow board business on the now read-only LNC public list.

LNC News covers the governance and internal affairs of the Libertarian National Committee. Tips and submissions can be sent to LNCnews.submissions@gmail.com.

This LNC News article has been read 73 times